60 Minutes Report: 2/16/03

In the 60 Minutes report below, the heartunethical business practices" in this 60 Minutes
surgeries were scheduled, and in many casesreport on one of the company's California
performed on healthy individuals with NO hearthospitals accused of performing unnecessary
problems. This abuse came to the surfaceheart surgeries. Bradley's report on Tenet Health
through patients seeking other opinions, butSystems' Redding Medical Center was broadcast
unfortunately not before 167 people died andon Sunday, Feb. 16, 2003 at 7 p.m., ET.
hundreds more received unnecessary surgery.Tenet hospitals have been the subjects of federal
It is much more realistic for that to happen inproceedings in FL orida for patient endangerment
colon surgeries, the abuse is much more tricFL toand in California for substantiation of illegal
recognize and/or expose. With colon diseases,kickbacks to doctors; the federal government is
there is usually a way to "rationalize" the surgerysuing Tenet for defrauding taxpayers. The FBI is
because there is almost always somenow investigating Tenet's Redding Medical Center,
inflammations, tissue irregularity or other damageand two of the hospital's doctors for purportedly
which the doctor can identify.recommending and performing avoidable heart
The problem is that there is not any system ofsurgeries. Tenet says they first learned of the
accountability in place today.complaints in October 2002, when the FBI raided
We are taught to trust "the physician" or get athe hospital and confiscated thousands of files,
second opinion, and in almost all cases the secondincluding those of 167 patients who died after
and/or third opinion can be as pro-surgery as theheart surgery.
first.Stark believes Tenet was aware of complaints
It is a lack of knowledge about other alternativesabout the doctors before that day, as well as Dr.
for treatment and a fear of lawsuits.Chae Hyun Moon, who ordered the alleged
To state the evident, doctors are progressivelysurgeries to be unwarranted, complaints which
more finding ways to validate surgery in an effortwere made for numerous years earlier to the FBI
to accommodate the lack of compensation fromraid.
the insurance companies for little things as office"When [Tenet] has documented charges by
visits.people who have called [Moon's] practice to their
Doctor's are too often interested in bottom lineattention time and time again, when their own
business to explore other options for theirnurses...other physicians were complaining," Stark
patients. It is a fact which the patients in mosttells Bradley, "It's pretty hard for somebody to
instances cannot bear to comprehend.say, 'Gee, we didn't know what was going on.'"
(CBS) Rep. Pete Stark (D-Calif.) tells Ed BradleyAdds Stark, "These guys are the poster children
that executives at the nation's second largestfor unethical business practices.
healthcare company are "poster children for