High Medical Costs Are Not the Root Cause For High Bankruptcy Rates

A recent study looked at the suggestion thatdespite their inclusive healthcare program, there
bankruptcy rates in the US could be dramaticallyare two things we can surmise. One is that,
reduced if a better health care system were inindeed, healthcare costs in the US, while high, are
place in America. While it is true that personaljust another of the many contributors to
bankruptcy rates in the United States havebankruptcy rates. In other words, it would be just
soared since the economy started to deteriorate,as "easy" to become bankrupt by racking up
the myth that health care costs are the drivingcredit card debt as it is to incur steep medical
factor is just that: a myth.expenses but the bottom line would be the same:
According to a recent study by Brett Skinner andincome cannot support debt levels that individuals
Mark Rovere, health care costs that are paid byincur.
the user do not impact bankruptcy filings. That isThe second assumption is that the systems by
not to say that high medical costs do notwhich individuals file for bankruptcy are very
contribute to bankruptcy filings, but overhaulingdifferent in both countries. For example, it may
the US Medical system alone will not have asimpler for people to file in Canada versus the
tremendous impact on bankruptcy.United States and the consequences of filing
The reason for bankruptcy is quite simple andmight be lighter in Canada versus the United
obvious (once revealed). And that reason is lackStates. However, this does not seem to be the
of income and savings. The study points tocase aside from one simple distinction.
Canada as an illustration that bankruptcy ratesIn Canada, Chapter 13 bankruptcy is referred to
and assisted or paid medicare are not linearlyas a consumer proposal. A consumer proposal
related. In fact, personal bankruptcy rates inallows for forgiveness on part of the consumer's
Canada were roughly 10% higher in the past twounsecured credit debt; in the US, Chapter 13
years. It is interesting to note that Canada has anwipes out unsecured credit debt.
assisted healthcare program that is so inclusive itUltimately, while medical costs are often cited as
is virtually paid for, yet their bankruptcy rates area reason for declaring bankruptcy, it is not the
quite a bit higher.root cause. Lack of income is.
If Canadian bankruptcy rates are so much high